|Primary ciliary dyskinesia in children
Discinesia ciliar primária na infância
|Maristella F. Toledo, Fabíola V. Adde|
|J Pediatr (Rio J) 2000;76(1):9-16|
Objective: To review the literature concerning primary ciliary dyskinesia as a cause of chronic respiratory disease in children.
Methods: Ten-year literature review of Medline records and other sources.
Results and conclusions: Primary ciliary dyskinesia is a disorder characterized by abnormal mucociliary clearance, affecting both the upper and lower respiratory tract. Clinical manifestations usually start in the first years of life, possibly leading to bronchiectasis. Kartagener's syndrome is the typical genetic manifestation. Diagnosis may be based on abnormal saccharin test results, but it must be confirmed by abnormal ultrastructure of the cilia or abnormal ciliary function. Treatment includes measures to enhance mucociliary clearance, such as physical therapy, prevention of respiratory infections by immunization, and early start of antibiotic therapy in the presence of acute respiratory infections.
Ciliary dyskinesia is the name attributed to diseases involving alterations in ciliary ultrastructure and/or function. As a consequence of these abnormalities, mucociliary transport is also affected.
Mucociliary clearance constitutes one of the most important defense mechanisms of the respiratory tract, whereby bacteria, viruses, allergens, and pollutants are driven to the oropharynx, where they are swallowed. The interruption of this mechanism, as in ciliary dyskinesia, results in clinical disease ().
The study of primary ciliary dyskinesia began about 90 years ago with the clinical observation of syndromes that included pulmonary diseases, sinopathy, situs inversus, and male infertility. Situs inver-sus and bronchiectasis were first described by Siwert in 1904 (). Kartagener, in 1933, carefully studied 11 patients with sinusitis, bronchiectasis, and situs inversus, suggesting that the existence of a common factor affecting all these patients. The triad became known as Kartagener's syndrome ( ).
Kartagener's syndrome had been previously called "immotile cilia syndrome," until researchers concluded that most cilia presented uncoordinated or dyskinetic movements, not necessarily being immotile (). It was only at that point that the name "primary ciliary dyskinesia" was proposed ( ). Primary ciliary dyskinesia is an autosomal recessive inherited disease, with an approximate incidence of 1:15-30.000 individuals ( ). It is classified as primary (congenital) or secondary (acquired).The most common defect is a deficiency in the number of dynein arms, resulting in weakening of the respiratory cilia and in spermatozoa motility.
Dyskinesia occurs in all sites presenting ciliated epithelium, i.e., nasal fossae, paranasal sinus, middle ear, tracheobronchial tree, ependyma, efferent ducts, uterine tube, cervix endometrium, and prolongations of retina cells (). In the present article, the literature concerning ciliary dyskinesia is reviewed taking into consideration the importance of the subject and the little knowledge about this disorder in the differential diagnosis of recurrent or chronic infections of the respiratory tract.
Before describing the main ciliary alterations that lead to ciliary dyskinesia, we review the current knowledge about morphology and normal mucociliary function (, , ).
a) Normal cilium ultrastructure
Figure 1 -Schematic representation of the eukaryotic cilium: spatial relations and position of main elements (adapted from Carson & Collier)
The internal structure of the axoneme presents microtubules arranged in an array of nine couplets surrounding two central singlets, establishing a characteristic "9 + 2" cilia pattern. The microtubules are formed by protofilaments made of tubulin protein. The outer couplets are divided into A and B. Each A microtubule presents two projections (dynein arms), which are classified as internal or external and arranged clockwise. The two arms are asymmetric, and have different polypeptide compositions.
Dynein is a protein found in the arms of microtubules. It is involved in the splitting of adenosine triphosphate molecules, and it is responsible for the liberation of the necessary amount of energy for the transport process. The outer microtubule couplets are linked by a slender filament composed of a protein called nexin.
Radial spokes are microstructures that connect the outer A microtubules to the central sheath. The central sheath is a discontinuous structure consisting of two rows of projections along each central microtubule. The ciliary hood involves the distal extremities of the central microtubules and of the A microtubules in the outer couplets.
The basal body is constituted by the basal corpuscle, which is similar to the centriole, involved in the formation of microtubules, and by the basal foot, a conic, short, dense, and striated structure, laterally projected from the medial region to the basal corpuscle. The basal foot seems to act as a supporting base during the stage of effective ciliary beating. The ciliary roots provide the axoneme anchorage. The transition zone ranges from the end of the basal corpuscle to the beginning of the central microtubules (Figure 2).
Figure 2 -Schematic representation of the basal body (adapted from Carson & Collier)
b) Ciliary movement
The waveform movements of the cilia are similar to that of the wind on a wheat field. A normal cilium moves forward in effective movement (1/5 of the cycle); then, it slowly recedes (4/5 of the cycle), in a sequential and metachronous recovery movement, reaching a peak length of approximately 20 mm. On average, cilia beat 20 times per second. Half of the dynein arms are involved in the effective movement, and the other half in the recovery movement (Figure 3).
Figure 3 -Schematic representation of ciliary beating. A) Effective movement of the cilia. B) Receding movement
During the effective movement, the arms extend at (approximately) 40º. This requires ATP hydrolysis, accomplished by the action of dynein, which is an ATPase. Radial spokes, which connect the outer microtubules to the central sheath, provide enough resistance to cause the cilia to bend as a result of the sliding process. The combination of sliding and microtubule resistance (tubulin-dynein interaction) is at the base of ciliary motility. The 5 mm thick mucosal surface moves upward at a speed of 0.5 mm to 1 mm per minute; thus, a particle adhered at the level of the bronchioloalveolar junction takes about 20 to 30 minutes to reach the pharynx, and about 30 minutes to reach the larynx.
Whenever there is an alteration in ciliary structure or function, there will be an alteration in mucociliary clearance, with stasis of the respiratory tract secretions, which will be responsible for the clinical manifestations of the disease.
c) Ultrastructural alterations in primary ciliary dyskinesia
d) Ultrastructural alterations in acquired ciliary dyskinesia
Bacterial or viral infections of the respiratory tract result in destruction of the ciliated epithelium and in altered ciliary beating rate, leading to mucociliary clearance delay. Other causes of acquired ciliary dysfunction are represented by the inhalation of cigarette smoke, toxic gases, environmental pollutants, or drugs, such as opium, atropine, cocaine and alcohol (, , ).
The most commonly acquired defects include compound cilia, addition and subtraction of microtubules, random orientation of the central microtubules, and alterations in the structure of the ciliary membrane. These defects are common in the general population, and their contribution to the increase of respiratory tract dysfunctions is more important than that of primary ciliary dyskinesia (, ).
For differential diagnosis between primary and acquired ciliary dyskinesia,
multiple samples of respiratory mucosa must be collected, at least twice,
from different sites (nose, trachea, and bronchi). The percentage of abnormal
cilia must be evaluated in a sample containing a large number of cilia.
The presence of the main ciliary defect in all analyzed samples will confirm
the diagnosis.8 In male patients, a concomitant spermatozoa alteration
excludes the possibility that ciliary defects are secondary to the infection
Primary ciliary dyskinesia may appear early in the neonatal respiratory distress syndrome (). However, in most cases, symptoms emerge during childhood. The severity of the symptoms varies considerably ( , ).
Upper respiratory tract
Sinopathy and recurrent or chronic otitis media, with suppuration and obstruction of the auditory tube, are also common. These disorders are attenuated with time. Some children may present permanent tympanic membrane perforation, or they might need multiple tympanostomies, with the insertion of a ventilation tube. As a consequence, these patients may suffer an auditory loss (, ).
Lower respiratory tract
Both lungs are equally involved, with predominant alterations on the lower and middle lobes and on the lingula, due to the greater difficulty in the drainage of secretions ().
The bacterial flora of primary ciliary dyskinesia patients resembles that of individuals suffering from chronic bronchitis. Haemophilus influenzae, Streptococcus pneumoniae, Staphylococcus aureus, and Streptococcus viridans are the usual pathogens ().
Dyspnea is an uncommon symptom. However, in some cases, an obstructive pattern is observed in pulmonary function tests ().
Physical exam may reveal signs of chronic pneumopathy, with an increase in the antero-posterior diameter of the thorax and digital clubbing in cases of greater pulmonary compromising. In cases of bronchiectasis, stertor can be observed on pulmonary auscultation. Bronchiectasis occurs in less than one-third of the children, and is usually more segmental than generalized. In adults, its incidence is greater, and indicates progressive lung damage. In some individuals, segmental and subsegmental atelectasis may be present (, ).
Congenital cardiopathies in association with primary ciliary dyskinesia were also reported ().
Similarly, female infertility is probably influenced by ciliary motility in primary ciliary dyskinesia, which is present in a great number of patients (, ).
Primary ciliary dyskinesia patients might report severe cephalea, which may reflect decreased circulation of cerebrospinal fluid, associated with impaired ciliary activity. Chronic infections of the frontal sinus also contribute to the appearance of this symptom ().
Other congenital anomalies associated with the syndrome include transposition of large vessels and pyloric stenosis (, ).
Diagnosis of primary ciliary dyskinesia must be based on the patient's
clinical history. Frequently, several specialists evaluate the child before
a definitive diagnosis is established. However, the most common causes
of respiratory diseases should be ruled out before the performance of
more specific exams.
Simple thoracic X-ray: reveals the degree of pulmonary involvement, with thickening of the bronchial walls, hyperinsufflation, possibly also showing bronchiectasis, atelectasis, condensation, and situs inversus. It usually shows greater damage in the middle lobe and lingula (Figure 4).
Figure 4 -Simple thoracic X-ray of a patient with Kartagener's syndrome, showing dextrocardia and gastric bubble on the right, and tenuous opacity in the base of the left lung
Frontal sinus X-ray: reveals mucous thickening or opacity of the paranasal
Figure 5 -Thoracic computed tomography of the same patient with Kartagener's syndrome, showing segmental atelectasis of the middle lobe on the left
Bronchography: occasionally indicated for patients with bronchiectasis, in order to evaluate surgical indications.
Pulmonary function test: evaluates the degree and type of ventilatory malfunctioning, usually obstruction (, ).
Audiometry: evaluates the degree of auditory impairment ().
a) Screening tests
1 - Saccharin test
2 - Radioisotopic test
b) Specific exams
1 - Ultrastructural evaluation of the cilia
Usually, when most cilia are abnormal, the study of nasal ciliated cells is sufficient to establish a diagnosis. Therefore, nasal biopsy must always come first, since it is less invasive than other techniques and can be performed in an outpatient setting, often dispensing with the use of topic anesthesia, which could influence ciliary clearance. However, nasal biopsy has one disadvantage: since the nasal mucosa is the site of frequent viral and bacterial infections, ultrastructural alterations in the cilia secondary to infectious processes may be observed. Therefore, nasal biopsy should be performed only after at least one month without acute respiratory infection. In cases of chronic rhinosinusitis, the nasal mucosa epithelium might already have suffered metaplasia, with few viable cilia for ultrastructural evaluation. In these cases, patients should undergo a treatment with antimicrobials for at least 2 weeks before biopsy, so that secondary ciliary alterations are minimized. Tracheal or bronchial biopsy is indicated when the analysis of the nasal biopsy is not enlightening.
2 - Functional evaluation of cilia
A fragment of respiratory mucosa biopsy should be placed in a specific medium, capable of maintaining the vitality of the cells, and then quickly sent to a laboratory for analysis.
Several methods have been developed to measure ciliary beat frequency and to analyze the shape of the ciliary motion (). These are sophisticated methods, demanding extensive training, and available in very few centers in Brazil or elsewhere. These methods are high-speed cinematography, laser light spectroscopy, photoelectric measurements, and stroboscopy. Ciliary beat frequency can be measured by any of these methods, but the analysis of ciliary movement can only be performed using high-speed cinematography; a video system can be used to evaluate the motion shape of ciliary beating. The analysis of ciliary movement is fundamental to understand ciliary function, since the cilia that seem to be immotile or even normal on optic observation might actually be uncoordinated or dyskinetic. Normal ciliary beat frequency usually ranges from 12 to 15 Hz, and in patients with primary ciliary dyskinesia, it is normally under 10 Hz ( , ).
Patient with sings and symptoms suggestive of primary ciliary dyskinesia
1) Thoracic X-ray
2) Saccharin test
3) Nasal biopsy ® electronic microscopy and functional evaluation of the cilia
Primary ciliary dyskinesia must be differentiated mainly from the following chronic pulmonary diseases: cystic fibrosis, asthma, immunodeficiencies, chronic aspiration, and bronchiectasis of other etiologies ().
Until this moment, there is no specific treatment to correct ciliary dysfunction. Development of a treatment will depend on further genetic and molecular research.
Patients benefit from the removal of secretion through regular respiratory physical therapy. In patients with ciliary dysfunctions, physical therapy should be similar to that used with cystic fibrosis patients (), using classic techniques, such as thoracic percussion, postural drainage, and techniques of forced expiration, and instruments such as the flutter and the positive expiratory pressure mask, which make physical therapy more efficient,. Patients must be stimulated to cough and to practice exercises that stimulate coughing, since this is an efficient mechanism for eliminating secretions. Prior to respiratory physiotherapy, inhalations with physiologic solution, mucolytics, or bronchodilators must be performed. Antitussive agents are strictly contraindicated.
Prophylactic measures, such as immunization against hemophilus, pneumococcus, and influenza, should be followed (). Patients should be advised to avoid exposure to smoke, pollutants, and allergens.
At the first sign of infection, therapy with antibiotics is indicated. The most commonly agents, Haemophilus influenzae and Streptococcus pneumoniae, deserve special attention. In patients presenting Haemophilus influenzae and Streptococcus pneumoniae, a regular sputum culture should be performed in order to monitor the bacterial flora of their respiratory tract and help in the selection of an antimicrobial agent when indicated. Antibiotics are usually used for two-week periods during acute exacerbations. In some cases, long-term prophylactic therapy with antibiotics may be required ().
Adequate hydration must be stimulated to maintain secretions fluid and
easy to eliminate. Mucolytics may be used in some cases. Bronchoscopy
is indicated if atelectasis does not respond to intense respiratory physical
Due to the chronic status of primary ciliary dyskinesia, patients should be followed by a multidisciplinary team including psychologists, speech therapists and otorhinolaryngologists.
In conclusion, primary ciliary dyskinesia may progress to chronic pulmonary disease; therefore, it should be considered in the differential diagnosis of chronic and repeated pneumopathies of the child. Early diagnosis and treatment can avoid, or at least delay the evolution of the disease into irreversible pulmonary lesions. A complete evaluation for the diagnosis of primary ciliary dyskinesia is sophisticated and expensive, leading to a situation of subdiagnosis of the disease in our setting. In cases of clinical suspicion based on suggestive signs and symptoms and on altered screening tests, the patient must be directed to a medical center equipped to perform ultrastructural and functional evaluation of cilia. Despite the evolution to chronic pulmonary disease, with bronchiectasis and some degree of respiratory failure, the course of primary ciliary dyskinesia is highly variable, and in many patients life expectancy is very close to normal.
The authors thank to Dr. Tatiana Rozov and Dr.Vivian Kiran Lee for the initial revision of the text.
|Maristella F. Toledo - Assistant Physician, Pediatric Service, University Hospital, Taubaté-UNITAU.|
|Fabíola V. Adde - Assistant Physician, Pulmonary Unit, Children's Institute, Hospital das Clínicas, FMUSP.|
|Top | Close|
|Title of the article: "Primary ciliary dyskinesia in children"|
|1. Le Mauviel L. Primary ciliary dyskinesia. West J Med 1991; 155:280-3.|
|2. Sleigh MA. Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia. Lancet 1981; 2: 476.|
|3. Rossman CM, Newhouse MT. Primary ciliary dyskinesia: evaluation and management. Pediatr Pulmonol 1988; 5:36-50.|
|4. Carson JL, Collier AM. Ciliary defects: cell biology and clinical perspectives. Adv Pediatr 1988; 35:139-66.|
|5. Rott HD. Genetics of Kartageners Syndrome. Eur J Respir Dis 1983; 64 (Suppl 127):1-4.|
|6. Paschoal IA. Ultraestrutura ciliar à microscopia eletrônica de transmissão: comparação da prevalência de anomalias ciliares entre pacientes portadores da síndorme de discinesia ciliar e indivíduos normais[dissertação].Campinas: Faculdade de Ciências Médicas, Universidade Estadual de Campinas; 1988. 252p.|
|7. Silveira IC, Abreu WM. Síndrome dos cílios imóveis. Med HUPE UERJ 1986; 5:49-55.|
|8. Barlocco EG, Valleta EA, Canciani M, Lungarella G, Gardi C, DeSanti M et al. Ultraestrutural ciliary defects in children with recurrent infections of the lower respiratory tract. Pediatr Pulmonol 1991; 10:11-17.|
|9. Rautianen M, Nuutinen J, Collan Y. Short nasal respiratory cilia and impaired mucoliary function. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 1991; 248:271-274.|
|10. Rutland J and De Iongh RV. Random ciliary orientation: a cause of respiratory tract disease. NEJM 1990; 24:1681-4.|
|11. Rayner CF et al. Ciliary disorientation alone as a cause of Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia syndrome. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1996; 153: 1123-1129.|
|12. Ballenger JJ. Acquired ultraestrutural alterations of respiratory cilia and clinical disease. Ann Otol Laryngol 1988; 97: 253-8.|
|13. Wilson R. Secondary ciliary dysfunction. Clin Sci 1988; 75:113-20.|
|14. Boat TF, Carson JL. Ciliary dysmorphology and dysfunction primary or acquired ? NEJM 1990; 323:1700-1702.|
|15. Leigh MW. Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia. In: Chernick V, Kendig EL Jr, Boat TF. Disorders of the respiratory tract in children. 6ª ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 1998. p. 819-25.|
|16. Whitelaw A, Evans A, Corrin B. Immotile cilia syndrome: a new cause of neonatal respiratory distress. Arch Dis Child 1981; 56:432.|
|17. Greenstone M, Rutman A, Dewar A, Mackay I, Cole PJ. Primary ciliary dyskinesia: cytological and clinical features. Q J Med 1988; 67:405-30.|
|18. Turner JAP, Corkey CWB, Lee JYC, Levison H, Sturgess J. Clinical expressions of immotile cilia syndrome. Pediatrics 1981; 67:805-10.|
|19. Hartline JV, ZelKowitz PS. Kartagener's syndrome in childhood. Am J Dis Child 1971;121:349.|
|20. Engesaeth VG, Warner VO, Bush A. New associations of Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia Syndrome. Pediatr Pulmonol 1993; 16:9-12.|
|21. Afzelius BA, Eliasson R. Flagellar mutants in man: on the heterogenity of the immotile cilia syndrome. J Ultrastruct 1979; 69:43.|
|22. Jewett MAS, Greenspan MB, Shier RM, Howatson AF. Necroespermia on immotile cilia syndrome as a cause of male infertility. J Urol 1980; 124:292.|
|23. De Santi MM, Magni A, Valletta EA, Gardi C, Lungarella G. Hydrocephalus, bronchiectasis, and ciliary aplasia. Arch Dis Child 1990; 65:543-4.|
|24. Fogaça HS, Houaiss MSA, Sant'Anna CC. Síndrome de Kartagener: atualização e apresentação de um caso. Folha Méd 1985; 90:329-31.|
|25. Nunesmaia HGS, Medeiros JEMF, Formiga NJS, Branco BC. Síndrome de Kartagener - Estudo de novos casos. JBM 1994; 67:132-8.|
|26. Martin Munoz F, Rodriguez JLE, Lizaldez EB, Casas JAO. Síndrome de Kartagener con ausencia de brazos internos de dineína. Presentación y comentarios sobre un caso. An Esp Pediatr 1991; 35: 214-6.|
|27. Kinney TB, De Lucca SA. Kartageners syndrome. Am Fam Physician 1991; 44: 33-4.|
|28. Olivan Del Cacho MJ, Escribano MAC, Aguilar MJC, Almazor JC, Ufarte CS, Sirven JS et al. Síndrome de Disquinesia Ciliar en la infancia: a propósito de un caso. An Esp Pediatr 1991; 34: 477-8.|
|29. Smallman LA. Primary ciliary dyskinesia and Youngs syndrome. Clin Otolaryngol 1989; 14: 271-8.|
|30. Bonneau D, Raymond F, Kremer C, Klossek JM, Kaplan J, Patte F. Usher Syndrome type I associated with bronquiectasis and immotile nasal cilia in two brothers. J Med Genet 1993; 30: 253-4.|
|31. Senent Sanchez CJ, Piris Pinilla MA, Gonzáles Gutiérrez ML, Panadero Sevilla P, Menéndez Lozano A. Procedimientos diagnosticos en la discinesia ciliar primaria. Utilidad de la biópsia nasal. Rev Clin Esp 1990; 186: 263-8.|
|32. Green CG. Using a curette to collect ciliated nasal epithelium for evaluation in patients with suspected primary dyskinesia. [Letter]. Pediatr Pulmonol 1990; 9: 131.|
|33. Rutland J, Cole P. Non invasive sampling of nasal cilia for measurement of beat frequency and study of ultrastructure. Lancet 1980; 2:564-5.|
|34. Hofler H, Gruber K, Stockinger L. The technique of taking brush biopsies of the nasal mucosa for electron microscopy. Wien Klin Wochenschvi 1992; 104:320-1.|
|35. Daugherty CC, Vogler C, Buchino JJ. Electron microscopy in the diagnosis of pediatric disease. Pediatr Clin North Am 1989; 36:216-27.|
|36. Canciani M, Barlocco EG, Mastella G, De Santi MM, Gardi C, Lungarella G. The saccharin method for testing mucociliary function in patients suspected of having primary ciliary dyskinesia. Pediatr Pulmonol 1988; 5:210-14.|
|37. Adde FV, Rozov T. Teste de sacarina em crianças. J Pneumol 1997; 23:66-70.|
|38. Paludetti G, Todisco T, Fedeli L, Giombini E, Rosignoli M, Almadori G. Radioisotopic method for nasal mucociliary function evaluation. Rhinol 1988; 26:257-62.|
|39. Buchdahl RM, Reiser J, Ingram D, Rutman A, Cole PJ, Warner JO. Ciliary abnormalities in respiratory disease. Arch Dis Child 1988: 63:238-43.|
|40. Rossman CM, Lee RMKW, Forrest JB, Newhouse MT. Nasal ciliary ultrastructure and function in patients with Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia compared with that in normal subjects and in subjects with various respiratory diseases. Am Rev Respir Dis 1984; 129:161-7.|
|41. Williams MT. Chest physiotherapy and cystic fibrosis. Why is the most effective form of treatment still unclear? Chest 1994;106:1872-82.|
|Top | Close|
| Copyright Sociedade Brasileira de Pediatria © 2001 - All rights reserved
All services in this site are free. This is possible thanks to a donation given by Nestlé Infants Nutrition